The Inner Critic: Friend or Foe?


Hi Reader,

You know that voice in your head after a bad race, a missed shot, or a tough training session?
The one that says: "You’re not good enough." "You’ll never make it." "Everyone else is better than you."

Yeah, that one. It’s brutal, isn’t it?

If you’ve ever caught yourself spiraling into harsh self-criticism, you’re not alone. Negative self-talk is one of the most common mental barriers athletes face.

And here's the weird part. The inner critic is not making you better. It’s holding you back.

When you constantly criticize yourself, it erodes your confidence, increases anxiety, and makes it harder to focus. It’s like trying to run a race with a 50-pound weight strapped to your back. So, what’s the alternative?

Self-compassion.

Before you roll your eyes and think, “That means going soft,” give me a moment.

Self-compassion isn’t about lowering your standards or making excuses. It’s about treating yourself with the same respect and understanding you’d offer a teammate who’s struggling.

Think about it: If your best friend missed a goal or had a bad race, would you tell them they’re a failure? Of course not.

You’d probably say something like, “Hey, it’s okay. Everyone has tough days. You’ll bounce back.”
So why not talk to yourself the same way?

Here’s a quick exercise to try this week:
1️⃣ Think about a recent setback or tough moment in your sport.
2️⃣ Write about it as if you’re talking to a close friend in the same situation.
3️⃣ Be kind, understanding, and encouraging.
To walk you through this exercise step by step, we've pulled our Self-Compassion exercise out of the Skadi resource vault to share with you! 👇🏻

This simple shift can help you break the cycle of negative self-talk and build a healthier, more resilient mindset.

Want to dive deeper into how self-compassion can transform your performance? Check out the latest blog post packed with practical tips and exercises you can start using today. 👇🏻


🎙️This week on the Feisty Women’s Performance Podcast, we welcome Dr. Margie Davenport to debunk common myths around pregnancy and postpartum exercise. This is a good one! Discover how your body’s adaptations during pregnancy can actually support your athletic performance, and why heavy lifting and high-intensity workouts may not be as risky as you think. Tune in for empowering insights that challenge outdated narratives!

If this resonates with you, hit reply and let me know: What’s one way you can practice self-compassion in your training this week?

Talk soon,
Dr. A

Ready to strengthen your mindset and perform at your best?
Explore our mental health therapy and performance coaching services —and book a free consultation to get started today.

Skadi Sport Psychology

Sign up to be the first to find out about new blog posts, podcasts, research opportunities, publications, and more.

Read more from Skadi Sport Psychology
Feelings of Never Being Enough: A Guide to Perfectionism for Athletes

Hi Reader,Calling all perfectionists in the house! For so many athletes, perfectionism feels like both a blessing and a curse. It’s what gets you out of bed for those early morning workouts. It’s what pushes you to dig deep when your legs are screaming to stop.It has a lot of different forms, and has created some interesting debates in the sport psychology world (good? bad? both?), but if there's anything I've learned, it's definitely a personality trait that you can't simply turn off. No one...

Calling All High School coaches! Is Your Team Culture Helping or Hurting?

Hi Reader,Let’s be real—coaching high school athletes is about so much more than training plans and race-day strategies.It’s about those moments that keep you up at night. Like when your top athlete pulls out of a race with a “stomachache” that’s really about anxiety. Or when you overhear a joke and wonder if your team culture is unintentionally pushing athletes away.Sound familiar? Your role as a coach goes far beyond teaching technical skills or improving race times. You’re shaping the...

Digital wellness and doing it for the 'gram': social media and athlete wellness

Hi Reader,Let’s talk about something that’s been on my mind lately (& on the minds of many of you, likely): social media.It’s a love-hate relationship, isn’t it?On one hand, it’s great to connect with teammates, share your wins, and find inspiration from other athletes. I love the sense of community I get from it, and the opportunity to connect with others regarding my random adventures. I've even done a surprising amount of networking on Instagram. (It's how I found some of you!)On the other...