Why ‘Just Be Confident’ Doesn’t Work--especially for girls & women


Hi Reader,

You know that moment when someone says, “Just be more confident!” and you want to roll your eyes so hard they might get stuck?

Yeah, me too.

If you’re a female athlete, you’ve probably heard this advice more times than you can count. And while it’s well-meaning, it’s also wildly unhelpful.

Here's why: Confidence for women in sports comes with a catch.

Be confident, but not too confident.
Be competitive, but don’t be aggressive.
Be a leader, but don’t be bossy.

It’s like walking a tightrope. And it’s exhausting.
Annnnnnd it’s not your fault.

This double standard is baked into the culture of sports—and society. While male athletes are often celebrated for their confidence, women are often labeled as arrogant or cocky for the same behaviors.

Here's where we stand at Skadi: Confidence is not arrogance.

Confidence is internal. It’s the quiet belief in your abilities, built through preparation, hard work, and experience. Arrogance, on the other hand, is external—a mask for insecurity that seeks validation from others.

The problem isn’t your confidence. It’s the cultural lens through which it’s viewed.

So, how do you build sustainable confidence without feeling like you have to apologize for it?
Here are three quick tips to get started:

1️⃣ Anchor Your Confidence in Your Work
Confidence isn’t about faking it—it’s about earning it and slowly working toward it over time. Reflect on the hours of practice, the sacrifices, and the progress you’ve made. Keep a training log or even a “confidence jar” to track your wins, big and small.

2️⃣ Redefine Success and Failure
Perfectionism is a trap. Growth isn’t a straight line—it’s messy, full of setbacks and plateaus. Instead of aiming for flawless, aim for progress. Every stumble is a step forward.

3️⃣ Practice Self-Compassion
Your inner critic can be loud, but it doesn’t have to take the driver's seat. Treat yourself like you’d treat a teammate—with kindness and encouragement. Celebrate the small wins, and remind yourself: You’re doing the work, and that’s what matters.

Confidence isn’t about changing who you are. It’s about owning who you are.

Ready to dive deeper, check out the latest blog post: “The Confidence Paradox: Why ‘Be More Confident’ Is a Trap for Female Athletes.”

Oh, and before I go—don’t miss this week’s episode of the Feisty Women’s Performance Podcast! I mean it. This was one of my FAVORITE episodes to record, and Dr. LaVoi is an absolute legend in the field. She'll help you understand why the confidence issues above aren't a you problem.

🎙️ 50 Years After Title IX: The Data on Gender Equity’s Unfinished Revolution with Dr. Nicole LaVoi.

Dr. LaVoi dives into the systemic barriers women face in sports coaching and shares actionable strategies for navigating male-dominated environments.

Til next time,
Dr. A

Ready to strengthen your mindset and perform at your best?
Explore our mental health therapy and performance coaching services —and book a free consultation to get started today.

Skadi Sport Psychology

Sign up to be the first to find out about new blog posts, podcasts, research opportunities, publications, and more.

Read more from Skadi Sport Psychology
Feelings of Never Being Enough: A Guide to Perfectionism for Athletes

Hi Reader,Calling all perfectionists in the house! For so many athletes, perfectionism feels like both a blessing and a curse. It’s what gets you out of bed for those early morning workouts. It’s what pushes you to dig deep when your legs are screaming to stop.It has a lot of different forms, and has created some interesting debates in the sport psychology world (good? bad? both?), but if there's anything I've learned, it's definitely a personality trait that you can't simply turn off. No one...

Self Compassion for Athletes how to navigate negative self-talk

Hi Reader,You know that voice in your head after a bad race, a missed shot, or a tough training session?The one that says: "You’re not good enough." "You’ll never make it." "Everyone else is better than you." Yeah, that one. It’s brutal, isn’t it?If you’ve ever caught yourself spiraling into harsh self-criticism, you’re not alone. Negative self-talk is one of the most common mental barriers athletes face.And here's the weird part. The inner critic is not making you better. It’s holding you...

Calling All High School coaches! Is Your Team Culture Helping or Hurting?

Hi Reader,Let’s be real—coaching high school athletes is about so much more than training plans and race-day strategies.It’s about those moments that keep you up at night. Like when your top athlete pulls out of a race with a “stomachache” that’s really about anxiety. Or when you overhear a joke and wonder if your team culture is unintentionally pushing athletes away.Sound familiar? Your role as a coach goes far beyond teaching technical skills or improving race times. You’re shaping the...